Mystery

Nothing chills the blood like a cold case. Search through our eerie tales of mystery, from unexplained disappearances and sudden vanishings to unsolved mysteries.

The Unknown Victorian Woman Murder of 1887

In 1887, four brothers stumbled across the brutalized body of a young woman in Rahway, New Jersey.

Unknown Patient 44170: The Bizarre Case of Bruneri-Canella

Unknown Patient 44170: The Bizarre Case of Bruneri-Canella

Giulia Canella swore the photo depicted her long lost husband. Was it really him?

A Journey of Death: What Happened to Ambrose Bierce?

Bierce sent a letter from Chihuahua, Mexico in 1913. It was the last anyone ever heard from him.

What Is the Truth Behind the Terrifying “Bitterroot Footage”?

Is this eerie video a viral stunt? Or something far more sinister?

Eleonore Zugun: The Ghost Girl of Romania

Was Eleonore Zugun truly possessed by the Devil?

Death By Fire: The Unsolved Case of the Rock Island Railroad Wreck of 1894

Death By Fire: The Unsolved Case of the Rock Island Railroad Wreck of 1894

It was one of the the largest instances of mass murder in Nebraska ... and remains unsolved to this day.

The Lineup’s Creepiest Stories of August 2016

From unsolved murder to the mysterious disappearance of a child genius, these creepy stories still send shivers down our spine.

Burned at the Stake: 5 Terrifying Witch Trials Throughout History

Terror, torture, and hysteria ran rampant when "witches" were put on the stand.

3 Haunting Questions About the Disappearance of Maura Murray

In 2004, young Maura vanished without a trace. Over a decade later, her case remains an utter mystery.

The Child Genius Who Vanished: What Happened to Barbara Newhall Follett?

Some believe she fled to the woods, just like the character from her famous novel.

The Lineup’s Creepiest Stories of July 2016

From sinister pacts to the blood-soaked history of an American murder house, these creepy stories still send shivers down our spine.

Vanished: The Unsolved Disappearance of Paula Jean Welden

She hiked into the woods one winter afternoon and was never seen again.

The Lineup’s Creepiest Stories of June 2016

From haunted trails to ghoulish serial killers, these creepy stories still send shivers down our spine.

Speaking with the Dead: An Interview with Psychic Profiler Robbie Thomas

Robbie Thomas’ psychic abilities have helped solve some gruesome crimes.

Police Gave This Child to the Wrong Family

In 1912, Little Bobby Dunbar went missing. Police found and returned a boy matching the missing child's description ... but was it really him?

The Lineup’s Creepiest Stories of May 2016

From psychotic children to haunted paintings, these creepy stories still send shivers down our spine.

Without a Trace: The Unsolved Disappearance of Dorothy Arnold

What happened to the vanished heiress on that fateful evening in 1910?

Bodies on the Hill: The Enduring Mystery of the Lead Masks Case

Their corpses were dressed in matching suits with homemade lead masks draped over their eyes...