Unsolved crimes, kidnappings left without resolution, and mysteries that will keep any internet sleuth puzzling all through the night.

Burned at the Stake: 5 Terrifying Witch Trials Throughout History

Terror, torture, and hysteria ran rampant when "witches" were put on the stand.

3 Haunting Questions About the Disappearance of Maura Murray

In 2004, young Maura vanished without a trace. Over a decade later, her case remains an utter mystery.

The Child Genius Who Vanished: What Happened to Barbara Newhall Follett?

Some believe she fled to the woods, just like the character from her famous novel.

The Lineup’s Creepiest Stories of July 2016

From sinister pacts to the blood-soaked history of an American murder house, these creepy stories still send shivers down our spine.

Vanished: The Unsolved Disappearance of Paula Jean Welden

She hiked into the woods one winter afternoon and was never seen again.

The Lineup’s Creepiest Stories of June 2016

From haunted trails to ghoulish serial killers, these creepy stories still send shivers down our spine.

Speaking with the Dead: An Interview with Psychic Profiler Robbie Thomas

Robbie Thomas’ psychic abilities have helped solve some gruesome crimes.

Police Gave This Child to the Wrong Family

In 1912, Little Bobby Dunbar went missing. Police found and returned a boy matching the missing child's description ... but was it really him?

The Lineup’s Creepiest Stories of May 2016

From psychotic children to haunted paintings, these creepy stories still send shivers down our spine.

Without a Trace: The Unsolved Disappearance of Dorothy Arnold

What happened to the vanished heiress on that fateful evening in 1910?

Bodies on the Hill: The Enduring Mystery of the Lead Masks Case

Their corpses were dressed in matching suits with homemade lead masks draped over their eyes...

The Forsaken Halls of England’s Severalls Hospital

On the outskirts of town lies a haunting remnant of Colchester's past...

The Lineup’s Creepiest Stories of April 2016

From haunted plantations to an unsolved axe murder, these creepy stories still send shivers down our spine.

Double Lives: 6 Infamous Real-Life Secret Identities

Everyone's got secrets, but few have double lives as shocking, daring, or strange as the ones listed here.

Clairvius Narcisse: The Real-life Vodou Zombie of Haiti

Eighteen years after family members buried his body, Clairvius Narcisse returned from the dead.

Death in Eyam: The Tragic Tale of England’s Plague Village

When the Black Plague arrived at Eyam's doorstep, its villagers were forced to choose between life or certain doom...

4 Freaky Cases of Skeletons Found in Unlikely Places

You never know what you’ll unearth in your own backyard…

The Legend of Bloody Mary

They say if you chant her name three times, a bloodied face will appear...