Mystery

Unsolved crimes, kidnappings left without resolution, and mysteries that will keep any internet sleuth puzzling all through the night.

GIVEAWAY: Enter for Your Chance to Win a Free Year of Creepy Crate!

We’re launching a new Instagram just for Creepy Crate—and we’re sharing the terror by giving away one year’s worth of eerie horror and true crime goodies!

These Compelling True Mysteries Have Kept Us Guessing for Years

The April/May Creepy Crate celebrates cold cases and unexplained mysteries from around the world.

Journey Into the Country’s Most Terrifying Urban Legends

Get a Creepy Crate full of spooky stories to share—and a free t-shirt when you subscribe!

Everything You've Ever Wanted to Know About Ed and Lorraine Warren

Were they paranormal investigators extraordinaire, or deceptive frauds?

It’s Been 50 Years Since D. B. Cooper Disappeared Into Infamy

50 years on, here’s everything you’ve ever wanted to know about the D. B. Cooper mystery.

Monstrous Creations Lurk Around Every Corner

This month’s Creepy Crate celebrates the creatures that make Halloween so terrifying.

Vera Renczi Was an Infamous Black Widow—Who May Never Have Existed

Did the supposedly infamous Romanian killer really slay 35 people? 

Lady Vanishes: The Mysterious Agatha Christie Disappearance

On a cold night in 1926, Agatha Christie vanished without a trace.

Travel Back to a More Terrifying Era

Creepy Crate is going totally 90s this month.

Secret in the Streets

For decades, strange plaques called Toynbee tiles have appeared like crop circles throughout the cities of the world.

The Dyatlov Pass Incident May Finally Be Solved

A new study put forth a compelling theory for this bizarre tragedy.

Crack Open a Crypt of Terror This Halloween

The October/November Crate is filled to the brim with spooky goodies.

Summer’s Nights Call for Terror in the Shadows

We’re sending horror straight to your doorstep.

All the Best Scares Are Indoors...

... and the newest Creepy Crate has arrived to terrify.

The Reaper's Sharing His Deadliest Gift Ever....

Will you roll the dice on this month’s Creepy Crate?

Darkness Gathers on the Horizon

A fresh decade of horror awaits in Creepy Crate #17.

Our Scariest Creepy Crate of the Year Is Nearly Sold Out!

This month's Creepy Crate is jam-packed with paranormal terror—and we're nearly sold out of 'em all!