Explore more of The Lineup's spookiest stories.

Was this horrendous cold case committed by someone close to home?

Fool the justice system once, shame on you. Fool them twice...

The victim at the center of America's first recorded murder trial refuses to rest.

It's the unanswered questions that consume us...

How many dark secrets was one New Mexico family hiding?

A hit slasher had two teenage boys conspiring to extinguish a young girl's life—and film it.

Wade into this tragic tale before diving into the illuminating new Showtime docuseries, Spector.

Three young girls had their lives gruesomely stolen—but could it have been prevented?

A man has been charged with the murders of Abby Williams and Libby German—but was he working alone?

What makes a young man turn against his own family?

Did she take her own life—or was it something more sinister?

Talk about fright on Halloween night.

How Lisa McVey got inside the head of notorious Florida serial killer Bobby Joe Long.

The case against the alleged killers of a young nursing student was as suspicious as the circumstances of her disappearance.

Discover your state's darkest secrets in this chilling series.

In the early 80s, a young suburban housewife stood at the center of a controversy including sex, lies, and an axe-murder.

The light of these shining stars was snuffed out all too soon.

A disturbing unsolved murder and the elusive suspect who disappeared without a trace.

The Lineup's community has terrifying taste—these are your most beloved titles.

One father survived only to lose his wife and children—but murder was just the tip of the iceberg.