• search-icon

The 20 Best Scary Movies of the Last 25 Years

We haven’t caught a wink since 1991—here’s why.

The horror genre serves up all kinds of scares. There are silly spooktastics like Drag Me to Hell and Tucker and Dale vs. Evil; pitch-black laugh riots like Attack the Block and Shaun of the Dead; and twisted mind-benders like The Cabin in the Woods and Pan’s Labyrinth.

Each one is a killer flick. But this list is reserved for those scary movies that still haunt our dreams years after we’ve seen them.

From killer kiddie vampires and spooky estates to undead ghouls and forests of pure evil, here are the best scary movies of the last quarter century. Sleep tight.

1. Let the Right One In

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Magnet Releasing

Children are creepy. Especially when their instincts are to bite into your jugular and suck out the blood. Tomas Alfredson’s Swedish gem centers on Oskar, a bullied loner who befriends a porcelain-faced vampire named Eli. Their budding friendship is a beautiful thing—albeit a gory one.

Related: Pint-sized Mayhem: 11 Scary Movies Starring Very Evil Children

2. The Blair Witch Project

50 horror movie facts: the blair witch project
  • Photo Credit: Artisan Entertainment

In 1994, this haunting little indie hit the silver screen and horror was never the same. Not only did the film’s “is-this-real?” PR hoax heavily impact today’s viral marketing model, it also triggered a wave of found-footage movies and proved that all one needs to make a killer horror flick is a handheld camera and a great idea. Our camping gear has collected dust ever since.

Related: Everything We Know So Far About the Mysterious New Blair Witch Movie

3. I Saw the Devil

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Magnet Releasing

Anyone who doesn’t consider Kim Jee-woon’s unflinching vision of vengeance a horror flick should just watch this. About a man out to avenge the murder of his wife, I Saw the Devil is a brutal watch. If ever there were a director who deserved the top honor for Best Revenge Flick—currently held by Park Chan-wook for Oldboy, of course—it’s this guy.

4. The Strangers

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Rogue Pictures

Liv Tyler and Scott Speedman star in one of the most terrifying films of 2008, and it doesn’t use a booming score or a ton of gore to achieve its goal. Rather, as the on-screen couple fights for their lives against a group of masked peeping toms, writer/director Bryan Bertino utilizes the sound of silence to scare the living daylights out of us. It’s highly effective.

5. You’re Next

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Lions Gate Films

This subgenre trailblazer about a dinner party from hell has a lot going for it. The cast, which includes indie film frequenters Joe Swanberg and Amy Seimetz, is on point; Simon Barrett’s story takes a killer feministic turn midway through; and mumblegore director Adam Wingard merges a home invasion nail-biter with the dysfunctional family drama to thrilling effect.

6. Paranormal Activity

really scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Paramount Pictures

Oren Peli’s paralyzing directorial debut introduced audiences to a new way of consuming supernatural movies. Through a series of security cams and handhelds, we’re invited to spy on the doomed horror stars and once and for all find out what happens when the lights go out. Now we wish we didn’t know.

Related: The 11 Scariest Haunted House Movies to Freak You Out in Your Own Home

7. The Babadook

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Causeway Films

Leave your gimmicks at the door, please. Good old-fashioned scares propelled director Jennifer Kent to icon status with her dark Aussie fairy tale. About a mother, her son, and the monster that lives in his closet, The Babadook was an insta-classic when it premiered at Sundance in 2014. And to think, this is just Kent’s debut.

8. 28 Days Later

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation

We’re not saying Danny Boyle invented the breakneck-speed zombie. But we are saying his cardio-inclined ragers win when it comes to scaring us out of our seats. With an atmospheric setting, crazy visuals, and a supreme score courtesy of John Murphy, 28 Days Later is an apocalyptic gem in a saturated subgenre. Making it to the closing credits is a workout in itself.

9. Audition

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Creators Company Connection

Google “most disturbing films of all time,” and odds are Takashi Miike’s 1999 atmospheric mail-order bride horror makes an appearance. And for good reason. About a widowed filmmaker who handpicks his wife from a lineup of leading lovelies, the tale quickly flips from wedded bliss to visceral nightmare complete with needles and piano wire.

10. The Witch

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Parts and Labor

Robert Eggers’s award-winning folktale paints a super-creepy portrait of Puritan-era New England, complete with wool petticoats and sinister goats. Dark forces are afoot after one family’s infant disappears into the dark wood. Viewer, prepare thyself for a coming-of-evil witch tale that’s chillier than the wintry temps these cursed homesteaders endure.

Related: The Witch: The Movie That Terrified Stephen King

11. The Descent

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Lionsgate Films

Writer/director Neil Marshall traps a group of spelunkers in an underground cave and then drops a bunch of rocks on them while launching a herd of subterranean humanoids at them. We had to take a few five-minute breathers during this one—usually in a wide-open, brightly lit space. And that is how you know you’re watching a premier horror picture.

Related: 12 Most Badass Women in Horror

12. Kill List

best horror directors kill list
  • Photo Credit: IFC Films

British director Ben Wheatley helms this marital drama-meets-crime thriller-meets-occult horror. Kill List tells the tale of a British soldier who attempts to re-enter the contract killing business, only to discover the dark world around him is more sinister than he imagined.

Related: 9 (More) Underrated Horror Movies You Need to Watch Right Now

13. Scream

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Dimension Films

Wes Craven is a master of teen scream films, and this one starring Neve Campbell as a high schooler on the run from the ghost-faced murderer of her mother just may be our favorite. Thanks to writer Kevin Williamson’s cleverly self-aware screenplay, and to the movie’s terrifying 13-minute opener, Scream still sends shivers down our spine.

14. Black Swan

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Fox Searchlight Pictures

Black Swan is a transcendent head-trip that spirals around a ballerina on the brink of breakdown. In the words of the film’s cracked protagonist Nina Sayers, “It was perfect.” Or in our words, “pretty damn close.”

15. It Follows

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Northern Lights Films

Yes, It Follows has been talked about to death. But it’s hard to find fault with David Robert Mitchell’s modern cautionary tale about the horrors of sexual encounters—from its perfect scream queen in Maika Monroe to its wicked synth-heavy Disasterpeace soundtrack.

16. Silence of the Lambs

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Orion Pictures

Jonathan Demme’s nightmarish crime thriller never fails to creep us. FBI agent Clarice Starling turns to cannibal killer Dr. Hannibal Lecter for help in hunting down a deranged murderer named Buffalo Bill. A glass of chianti, anyone?

Related: 9 Creepy Cannibal Movies That Will Make Your Skin Crawl

17. The Ring

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: DreamWorks

We can thank director Gore Verbinski for helping J-horror cross the Pacific; his remake of Hideo Nakata’s Ringu is the first to translate the subgenre for American audiences. About a journalist investigating the sinister origins of a cursed videotape, it’s one of those we still have trouble getting through without hitting pause.

18. Seven

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: New Line Cinema

David Fincher has a dark side, and it shines in this disturbing horror crime thriller. Seven follows a pair of detectives as they track down a sicko murdering urbanites living in sin, and culminates in one of the most horrific scenes ever shot. All we have to say is “What’s in the box?”

Related: 17 Surprisingly Smart Horror Movies

19. The Orphanage

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Esta Vivo! Laboratorio de Nuevos Talentos

Producer Guillermo del Toro and director J. A. Bayona’s El Orfanato is a Spanish Gothic horror that, at first blush, looks familiar. But with a nuanced approach and a standout performance from lead actress Belén Rueda, the filmmakers have crafted an eerily atmospheric masterpiece about a mother who plays hide-and-seek with child ghosts in hopes of finding her missing son.

20. The Others

best scary movies
  • Photo Credit: Cruise/Wagner Productions and Dimension Films

In his first English-language film, Alejandro Amenabar puts Nicole Kidman in a haunted country house on an island in the English Channel and then sends a wave of chills down our spine. The Others is about a widow, her sickly children, and the troubled souls roaming through their sprawling mansion. It’s also a ghost story that doubles as a portrait of grief, and possesses one twist ending tease that still satisfies all these years later.

Published on 07 Sep 2016

scroll up