We Value Your Privacy

This site uses cookies to improve user experience. By continuing to browse, you accept the use of cookies and other technologies.


10 Everyday Phrases with Very Disturbing Origins

Being caught red-handed has a much bloodier meaning than you think.


A good rule of thumb? Don’t fly off the handle … or you may lose your head.

From flesh-eating felines to paying through the nose with blood, the disturbing origins of these everyday phrases are sure to send a chill down your spine.


Paying Through the Nose

If you think paying through the nose is unappealing now, you would have hated it in 9th-century Ireland when the Danes conquered the Irish. Danish forces imposed a census poll tax during their reign, and refusal to pay came with a steep price: Collectors would slit one’s nose from tip to eyebrow.


Frog in Your Throat

Got a cold? Your hoarse voice may make it sound like you’ve got a frog in your throat. In the Middle Ages, however, you’d have one in there for real. Healers sometimes treated infections like thrush by putting an amphibian into a patient’s mouth—it was thought that the slimy creature would absorb the infection into its own body.


Gone to Pot

phrases origins

Photo: Hulton Archive / Getty Images

Today, when something’s “gone to pot” it’s fallen apart. But when it first surfaced in the 16th century, the phrase referred to what was going into the vessel; namely, freshly harvested meat and vegetables. A far grislier theory, however, suggests it refers to those who were boiled alive as punishment—or individuals who fell victim to cannibals.


Rule of Thumb

[UPDATE]: While the phrase dates back to as early as 1692 and is likely connected to carpentry,  its more violent connotation can be traced to 1782. That’s when English judge Sir Francis Buller allegedly stated that “a man was entitled to beat his wife with a stick, provided it was no thicker than his thumb.” The comment inspired caricaturist James Gillray to pen a cartoon depicting Buller offering a bundle of sticks as a “cure for a nasty wife.”


Caught Red-Handed

If you were caught red-handed in Scotland in the 15th century, you were caught with blood on your hands, likely right after a murder or after butchering another person’s livestock.


Cat Got Your Tongue?

phrases origins

Photo: Print Collector / Getty Images

There are two popular theories behind the origin of this phrase, and both sound painful. Some say the “cat” is a reference to a cat-o-nine-tails whip used by everyone from prison wardens to English naval officers—a flogging with one was so painful that you wouldn’t be able to talk after your punishment. But a flogging seems downright pleasant when compared to the punishment for blasphemy in medieval times: having your tongue cut out and fed to cats.


Fly Off the Handle

Flying off the handle is an embarrassing habit. But back in the day, it was downright deadly. The handle in question was an axe handle. As for the flying? Well, that was in reference to a poorly fastened axe head prone to flying off its handle—especially when a woodcutter got a little too vigorous with the woodcutting.


Mad as a Hatter

phrases origins

Photo: Apic / Getty Images

Often mistakenly attributed to the Hatter character in Lewis Carroll’s Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, this phrase actually goes all the way back to the 17th and 18th centuries. Hat makers often used mercury in hat felt during this period, developing mercury poisoning and symptoms like slurred speech, tremors, and hallucinations.


Saved by the Bell

It’s not just your favorite ’90s sitcom. Rumor has it that the etymology of this phrase comes from safety coffins patented during the 18th and 19th centuries. The coffins were outfitted with a cord that led to a bell above ground, making it easy for anyone accidentally buried alive to alert graveyard workers.


Rake Over the Coals

If you were raked over the coals in the Middle Ages, you were being accused of witchcraft. If you survived having your body dragged over red-hot coals, congratulations—you’re innocent!

[via 11Points.com; Telegraph; Mental Floss; Mental Floss; Mental Floss; Neatorama; Mirror; HistoryExtra.com; New York Times]

Feature photo: Lance / Flickr [CC]