5 Scary Childhood Stories—And Their Terrifying Horror Movie Adaptations

The Boogeyman, a chilling figure woven into the fabric of childhood nightmares, has been haunting various cultures for centuries. Parents often share its tale, a mix of disciplinary fable and an eerie bedtime story, to prey on disobedient children.

The term 'boogeyman' embodies the unknown terror, evoking images of unseen threats lurking in the shadows. This undefined fear of the Boogeyman being anywhere, in any form, and striking anytime, amplifies its terror.

John Carpenter's Halloween (1978) and The Boogeyman (2023) are two notable horror films inspired by the Boogeyman's narrative. 

In Halloween, Michael Myers, or 'The Shape,' plays the Boogeyman. His white mask dehumanizes him into an anonymous terror agent lurking in Haddonfield's quiet shadows. Moreover, his persistence and invulnerability, always returning no matter the defeat, underline the Boogeyman's relentless nature, heightening the audience's dread.

The newly released adaptation of Stephen King's renowned short, The Boogeyman (2023), tells a chilling tale. In the original story, Lester Billings seeks help from a psychiatrist about his three young children's mysterious deaths. Each child cried out about the "Boogeyman" before mysteriously dying from unrelated causes in their solitary rooms. Despite Billings insisting he had shut them, the closet doors were ajar at each death scene - an uncanny, persistent commonality. This psychological horror entwines dread, mystery, and the unexplained into a narrative, holding viewers in suspense.

Both films use the Boogeyman's embodiment of unseen fear, showing the myth's malleability and enduring relevance in horror cinema. Regardless of its form, the Boogeyman exploits our innate terror of the unknown, sustaining its menacing presence in folklore and cinema.

Since the 1960s, the American urban legend "The Babysitter and the Man Upstairs," a chilling tale of violated sanctity and betrayed trust, has captivated horror audiences.

From Black Christmas to When a Stranger Calls, the "Babysitter and the Man Upstairs" myth showcases the power of fear, proving horror can lurk in our homes where we least expect it.

The 1974 film Black Christmas first introduced this myth to the cinema, where unsuspecting sorority sisters receive threatening calls from within their house, turning their merry holiday into a horrifying ordeal.

When a Stranger Calls (1979) further cemented the legend in horror cinema with its suspenseful narrative. A lone babysitter in a large house receives unnerving calls from a man already inside, solidifying the "unsafe safe place" trope in home-invasion films.

The 2006 remake of When a Stranger Calls revitalized the legend in an isolated, opulent house. Caller ID revealing the terrifying truth—"The call is coming from inside the house"—demonstrates how technology can heighten insecurity rather than provide safety.

"Say her name thrice in the mirror, and she shall appear." This incantation lies at the heart of the Bloody Mary legend, a terrifying tale rooted in various histories and folklore. This ritual, needs only a dark room, a mirror, and the courage to utter the third 'Bloody Mary,' transforming the mirror from a vanity tool into a supernatural portal.

Candyman (1992) presents a similar premise where speaking Candyman's name five times in front of a mirror summons him. This film blurs the line between myth and reality, questioning fear and the consequences of obsession, adding layers of racial and social commentary.

The 2021 Candyman introduces a new entity and includes commentary on racial injustice, demonstrating the horror of cyclical violence and historical atrocities.

Urban Legend follows a murderer using various urban legends, including Bloody Mary, to commit chilling crimes. This direct use of the Bloody Mary legend reminds us of the potential danger hidden in seemingly innocent rituals.

Through their summoning rituals, these films give myths an absolute horror, indicating the real-world consequences of dismissed tales, thus highlighting the enduring power of folklore. 

The legend of the Tooth Fairy is deeply ingrained in the childhoods of many, particularly in the United States and other English-speaking countries. This figure is often portrayed as a benign, pixie-like character that rewards children for their lost teeth. The ritual holds a certain charm and excitement, promising to find a coin or a small gift left by the benevolent tooth collector.

However, beneath the veneer of childhood innocence, the concept of a magical entity entering a child's room while they sleep to claim a body part can be inherently unsettling, leading to horror reinterpretations, such as in Darkness Falls (2003).

Darkness Falls transforms the Tooth Fairy into a vengeful spirit attacking children when they lose their last baby tooth. The town is haunted by Matilda Dixon's ghost, a woman unjustly accused of kidnapping, known for giving children coins for their lost teeth. As the malevolent Tooth Fairy, her spirit hunts victims in the dark, turning an innocent myth into relentless terror.

This reinterpretation presents the Tooth Fairy as a horrifying figure exploiting vulnerability during the night and symbolizing the thin line between comfort and fear, revealing the dual nature of childhood myths. As filmmakers keep experimenting, we can anticipate more terrifying transformations of seemingly innocent tales, with the Tooth Fairy embodying our anxieties about innocence lost and the darker side of growing up.

Originating from the 1950s, it centers on a young couple parked in a secluded spot who dismisses a radio warning about an escaped hook-handed prisoner. This tale embodies fears of young love, rebellion, and disobeying societal norms.

In each of the films below, the Hook isn't just a physical threat but a symbol of impending adulthood, responsibility, and the consequence of actions, manifesting guilt and unresolved past mistakes. This enduring relevance and potency ensure the Hook legend will continue influencing horror cinema, exploring fears tied to adolescence and societal norms.

Tom Hanks' first feature film, He Knows You're Alone (1980), incorporated the Hook myth into a movie-watching scene, adding extra tension and highlighting horror's self-referential nature. 

The cult classic I Know What You Did Last Summer (1997) modernized the legend, featuring the Hook as a vengeful fisherman haunting a group of friends over a covered-up accident. 

Meanwhile, Urban Legend (1998) paid direct homage to the Hook myth, presenting it as one of several horrifying urban legends tormenting college students.

Enjoy what you've read here? Hack or Slash podcast has lots more where that came from. 

Hack or Slash is a horror movie review podcast dedicated to telling you whether a particular movie is a hack (a total joke, a waste of time) or a slash (totally killer, pun intended).

We believe horror is for everyone, regardless of how familiar you are with the genre, or which flavor of fear you fancy most. We recognize that each film lands differently with viewers, with perceptions colored by the prism of our personal experiences. To truly embrace this diversity, we've brought together a panel from varying socioeconomic backgrounds, bringing their unique lenses to each film review. This medley of perspectives not only enriches our discussions but underscores the fundamental essence of our show.

Each episode kicks off with a spoiler-free overview, allowing listeners to gauge whether the film fits their taste before delving into any revealing details. Post spoiler break, we plunge into a comprehensive analysis, scrutinizing the intensity of the film's gore, the complexity of its characters, and the caliber of its production.

The podcast launched on Friday, Oct. 13, 2017 (nice) and is available for streaming and download in Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, and Spotify, among other major podcast platforms.