We Value Your Privacy

This site uses cookies to improve user experience. By continuing to browse, you accept the use of cookies and other technologies.


11 Creepy New TV Shows We’re Dying to See This Fall

Dim the lights ...


Fall TV season is finally here, and we’re thrilled about the killer programs soon-to-be lurking on our DVR. Granted, we’re still buzzing about the return seasons of Top of the Lake and The Fall—and don’t get us started on the mysterious season of American Horror Story. For this roundup, however, we’re sticking to the new stuff.

Herewith, 11 shiny-as-a-knife new shows to get your creepy TV fix this fall 2016.

1. Quarry on Cinemax

Premiered: Friday, September 9 at 10pm EST

fall tv shows quarry
  • camera-icon
  • Photo Credit: Still from Quarry via Cinemax

Based on Road to Perdition co-creator Max Allan Collins’s crime novels, Quarry is the collaborative result of Rectify’s Graham Gordy and Michael D. Fuller, with Banshee’s Greg Yaitanes directing. Their narrative takes a scathed Vietnam vet from the bloodbath overseas to the mob-ruled killing fields dotting the Mississippi River. Logan Marshall-Green, who you should recognize from spring’s sleeper hit The Invitation, takes the lead as Mac “Quarry” Conway. Trust us, these are eight episodes of intensity you want in your streaming arsenal.

2. The Case of: JonBenet Ramsey on CBS

Premiers: Sunday, September 18 at 8:30pm EST

fall tv shows jonbenet ramsey
  • camera-icon
  • Photo Credit: Promotional Still from The Case of: JonBenet Ramsey via CBS

The unsolved case of slain six-year-old beauty princess JonBenet Ramsey gets small-screen attention in the form of a six-hour docuseries. In it, the very same investigators from the original investigation reunite to dig into files and pursue the leads they once had on their lists. Yes, you’ll see other networks airing retrospectives, but this is the only real-time investigation going down—and like ESPN’s gripping O.J. epic, this one offers closure.

Related: The New Trailer for “The Case of: Jonbenét Ramsey” Will Make Your Blood Run Cold

3. The Exorcist on Fox

Premiers: Friday, September 23 at 9pm EST

fall tv shows the exorcist
  • camera-icon
  • Photo Credit: Still from The Exorcist via Fox

First things first: This is not a remake. Creator Jeremy Slater wants everyone to know that his serialized thriller is really a continuation of the horrors that happened more than 40 years ago. But not so fast—the plot remains close to home. A couple of priests come to the aid of an American family, the Rances (with matriarch Geena Davis), who are being terrorized by the sinister uninvited. Of course, this is Fox—not Friedkin—but we’re still hoping for moments of spilled pea soup.

Related: 9 Unholy Demonic Possession and Exorcism Movies

4. Channel Zero: Candle Cove on Syfy

Premiers: Tuesday, September 27 at 9pm EST

fall tv shows channel zero
  • camera-icon
  • Photo Credit: Still from Channel Zero via Syfy

A six-episode anthology series based on the Creepypasta short story by Kris Straub, Channel Zero: Candle Cove comes from a pair of accomplished storytellers: Max Landis (who wrote Chronicle) and Nick Antosca (who wrote for Hannibal). The show, which kicks off with a group of people all having the same nightmares after watching a mysterious show, claims its M.O. is “to get weird” with the genre. And if the toothy teasers are any indication, we’re in store for a creep fest with serious bite.

5. Westworld on HBO

Premiers: Sunday, October 2 at 9pm EST

fall tv shows westworld
  • camera-icon
  • Photo Credit: Still from Westworld via HBO

Crafted by creative powerhouses Lisa Joy and her husband, Jonathan Nolan (yes, that Nolan), Westworld is a bit of a head-scratcher. Stick with us: It’s a futuristic show about robots and cowpokes acting out their every carnal and violent desire in a dystopia where Anthony Hopkins is God. A remake of Michael Crichton’s 1973 sci-fi classic, it also stars Evan Rachel Wood and Ed Harris, and will play out like a 10-hour movie—with trademark TV cliffhangers, we hope?

6. Falling Water on USA

Premiers: Thursday, October 13 at 10pm EST

fall tv shows falling water
  • camera-icon
  • Photo Credit: Still from Falling Water via USA Network

A dream thriller starring a diverse cast under the direction of 28 Weeks Later’s Juan Carlos Fresnadillo, Falling Waters pivots around three strangers who find they’re not only sharing the same dream but can enter the dreams of others. It’s a lofty concept—one that Christopher Nolan pretty much perfected on the big screen—but after the success of the network’s genius Mr. Robot, we can’t help but be intrigued.

7. Wolf Creek on Pop

Premiers: Friday, October 14 at 10pm EST

fall tv shows wolf creek
  • camera-icon
  • Photo Credit: Still from Wolf Creek via Emu Creek Pictures

You know the based-on-true-events story already: Aussie serial killer turns the Outback into his own bloody playground littered with the bodies of tourists and backpackers. Well, now there’s a six-episode miniseries about it. Though, of course, the plot veers a bit off course—in a good way. This time, it’s the killer who’s the hunted. The hunter? Eve Thorogood, the 19-year-old seeking revenge for her slaughtered family. She’s played by rising star Lucy Fry. This one should be fun.

Related: 11 Things You Need to Know About Australia’s Backpacker Murders 

8. Chance on Hulu

Premiers: Wednesday, October 19 [Air Time TBD]

fall tv shows chance
  • camera-icon
  • Photo Credit: Still from Chance via Hulu

The doctor is back, though this time House is shrouded in mystery. Room’s Lenny Abrahamson directs Hugh Laurie in a taut psychological thriller about an SF neuro-psychiatrist who gets a bit too chummy with one of his patients and then finds himself tangled up in a violent and dark world populated with schizos and corruption. Yeah, sign us up.

9. Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency on BBC America

Premiers: Saturday, October 22 at 9pm EST

fall tv shows Dirk Gently
  • camera-icon
  • Photo Credit: Still from Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency via BBC

This buddy sleuth mystery series blends supernatural crime work with dry wit. What’s more, it comes from Douglas Adams, the mind behind the Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy series. Tack on a couple of Walking Dead producers, and you’ve got a recipe for fandom.

10. Undercover on BBC America

Premiers: Thursday, November 17 [Air Time TBD]

fall tv shows
  • camera-icon
  • Photo Credit: Still from Undercover via BBC

Anglophiles, rejoice, there’s a British political thriller built on sex, lies, and secrets from BAFTA-winning Peter Moffat on the docket this November. And even though Moffat touts his six-episode miniseries as an “uncompromising and surprising thriller,” it’s the presence of Allstate’s Dennis Haysbert as a wrongfully convicted man on death row that has us nodding in approval. Guess we’re in good hands, huh?

11. Midnight, Texas on NBC

Premier Date and Time TBD

fall tv shows midnight texas
  • camera-icon
  • Photo Credit: Still from Midnight, Texas via Universal Television

Think True Blood on prime time. Still interested? So are we. Based on the novel series by Charliane Harris, Midnight, Texaswill soon see the light of day with all of its wolves, weirdos, and vamps. The show comes from Niels Arden Oplev, who directs Mr. Robot, so we’re hoping he can do for supernatural phenomena in Small Town, USA, what he does for vigilante hackers in corporate America.

Still from "The Exorcist" via Fox